A good glass eyeliner is a bit of a Goldilocks situation. You wish something that stays put though is easy to mislay when we wish to, something that goes on uniformly though doesn’t run or bleed, and something that can emanate both a super accurate line and an fashionable striking eye.
You’ve got options, of course—maybe even too many. A discerning hunt on Amazon will lift adult some-more than 6,000 regulation trimming from drugstore favorites to under-the-radar K-beauty gems. That’s a lot to arrange through. Luckily a tradesman has highlighted a number-one-selling eyeliner, a cult favorite Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen.
Stila’s ship boasts 5,229 reviews, with 4,053 of them being 5 stars, that is flattering damn impressive. The ship coop is good desired in a attention and has a repute for being a best of a best in glass liners, and a reviews endorse that. Thousands of them sing a praises of a staying power, observant it lasted by a 13-hour shift, sweaty examination class, or outing to a waterpark. Shoppers were also discerning to regard a liner’s palliate of use, with one legally blind user essay that it’s a usually eyeliner she’ll ever use.
Still, we never accurately know with reviews. So we had 5 Glamour staffers put a ship to a exam to see how it stacks adult to a favorites. Here are a honest thoughts.
Tara Gonzelez, commerce editor
I am notoriously bad during eyeliner, that is unequivocally comfortless since we adore it so much. we usually have unequivocally large eyes (and so unequivocally large eyelids), so we find sketch a good cat eye impossibly hard. This eyeliner unequivocally does live adult to a hype, and we was means to emanate my ideal cat eye in one stroke, that never ever happens. It’s also a ideal tone black and lasts literally all day.
Khaliha Hawkins, producer
After perplexing this for a initial time, we now know because so many people adore this eyeliner. we adore that a tip on it is unequivocally skinny and stiff. A lot of eyeliners I’ve attempted that exaggerate about a skinny tip are groundless and don’t yield a tangible line, though this was a exception. The tip indeed authorised me to pierce faster to make a straighter line. As someone who has nonetheless to ideal my eyeliner technique, we can contend this coop is ideal to assistance me get there.
Bella Cacciatore, beauty associate
I used this religiously in high school, though this is my initial time regulating it in a few years, and we can endorse it’s still a best. It unequivocally stays on forever: I’ve cried in it many times, and a good crony of cave sleeps in it so she usually has to request it each other day. It’s jet black and doesn’t patch off when we supplement some-more ink on tip to scold a line, that is my biggest pet peeve. The regulation is super smooth, doesn’t lift on your eye, and doesn’t drain so it’s easy to get a good wing. we generally cite a brush tip over a felt—it’s a small easier to control—which is a reason we stopped regulating it in a initial place, though when it comes to staying energy and inkiness, a Stila can’t be beat.
Lindsay Schallon, comparison beauty editor
I have deep-set eyes that eat eyeliner for breakfast. Cat eyes are subsequent to unfit to do on me (even pro artists onslaught with it), so we don’t wear black eyeliner all that mostly anymore. But when we do, we adore a thick black line that emphasizes a bottom of my lashes to make them demeanour fuller and thicker. I’ve attempted many of a “best glass eyeliners” over a years, and this is right adult there on a list. The coop itself is not too prolonged or clunky like some others. The felt tip glides uniformly and doesn’t skip or drag—or a worst, bleed, withdrawal we with a large black ink blob on your eyes. (My pretence for removing a ideally true line is to use my pinkie finger as an anchor on my impertinence to assistance keep my palm steady.) As for black smudges on my brow bone by midday? There were none. The ship truly stays where we put, no matter how inspired your eyelids are.
Kim Fusaro, executive of branded content
So we did not comprehend when we volunteered to test-drive an eyeliner that it was a liquid eyeliner, though when this landed on my desk, we knew we didn’t have a choice. (You usually don’t cranky a Beauty Closet Mafia.) I’ve always been intimidated by glass liner, though I’ve also always been a nerd, so we figured we could investigate my approach out of disaster. Turns out, we hardly had to. With one video, 9 eyeliner hacks, and a pep speak from Lindsay, we pulled off a sincerely important cat eye on a initial try. (Hey, I’m not going pro anytime soon, though we wouldn’t be ashamed to leave home like this.) It might’ve been beginner’s luck, though we consider this sold ship had something to do with it. The superfine indicate meant we could use little strokes and work slowly; it was some-more like essay on my skin with a fine-point Sharpie than requesting finger paint with a Q-tip, that is what we had been envisioning. we don’t consider glass ship will be in my daily revolution any time soon—it was a slow process—but I’ll really play with this one again.
Bella Cacciatore is a beauty associate at Glamour. Follow her on Instagram @bellacacciatore_.*